Overall thoughts: I give this box a rating of 5/5. Box is worth well over $10, they are deluxe size samples and I will use all of them!
5.) theBalm cosmetics Stainiac in Beauty Queen | I got this in my first (or at least one of my first) Birchbox's ever a couple years ago. I have not gotten one or bought one since. I chose this as my sample since I loved it before and I did not really need or want any of the other samples (see above). Full Size, $17
I love how they do the pick your own samples now. They either offer you a box in which you know all the samples you will get or you can choose the classic mystery Birchbox in which you can choose one sample and have the rest be a surprise. I personally like the surprise but it is nice to at least choose ONE of the samples!